Are Your Agencies Diluting Your Brand's Essence?

In my two decades of navigating the complex tides of marketing for food, beverage, outdoor lifestyle, adventure, and travel brands, I've seen first-hand the pitfalls large corporations face when managing their brands through multiple agencies. Today, I want to clarify how this can lead to diluted brand messaging and suboptimal outcomes. As a strategist at the helm of numerous campaigns, I've observed the chaos that ensues when too many cooks are in the kitchen—or, in this case, too many creatives on the conference calls.

The Core Issue: Too Many Voices

When a big corporation collaborates with multiple agencies, the array of creative input and the sheer volume of opinions can be staggering. For instance, the recent preparations for a beverage brand x shoe brand collaboration for the campaign related to the launch of a new line of beverages reveal a convoluted mesh of deliverables spanning several agencies, each bringing its own flavor to the table. Here lies the first issue: no singular forceful protection of the brand's essence. With deliverables scattered across various groups—from one agency's post-production tasks to another's media planning—there's a palpable lack of unified vision.

The Impact of Dispersed Creative Efforts

Consider the case of this campaign to introduce a new line of beverages, where the outreach includes everything from airport sampling stands to social media management and influencer marketing. The effort, though ambitious, runs the risk of creating disjointed customer experiences. Each agency, while expert in its own right, naturally leans towards strategies that highlight its strengths rather than those that might best serve the brand. This phenomenon is evident in the strategy employed for the national promotion of a day named after a drink recipe and the engagement in various city-specific events.

A Personal Reflection on Brand Cohesion

Reflecting on my early days producing broadcast TV for outdoor adventures, I learned that the most memorable stories and successful brands maintained a laser-sharp focus on their core message. This focus seems amiss in today's fragmented approach, where, for example, the different tactics for a summer campaign project are less about echoing the brand's 'soul' and more about leaning into each agency's abilities.

What Could Change?

Centralized Leadership: One dedicated brand leader with deep knowledge of the brand and consumers could make a significant difference. This person's responsibility should be to maintain the brand's values and ensure that every piece of creative aligns with these values.

Consolidated Feedback Loops: Instead of multiple agencies working in silos, a centralized feedback system could streamline communications. This would help quickly identify misalignments with the brand.

Selective Agency Engagement: Engage with agencies with a deep understanding of the brand's essence. This could mean fewer agencies but better synergy and understanding across all campaigns.

Have you faced similar challenges in your branding efforts? How have you kept the brand's essence intact amidst various external pressures?

As we navigate the complexities of marketing in a saturated media landscape, let's remember the importance of keeping our brand alive in every campaign. It's Not Just about making noise; it's about making a difference that resonates with our audience and stays true to our core values.

This post isn't a reflection—it's a call to action for all those in leadership roles to rethink how they manage the myriad creative inputs that come with big brand campaigns. Prioritize protecting your brand's reputation, even if it means redefining your relationships with the agencies you choose to partner with. After all, in the rugged terrain of marketing, it's vision and resolve that guide you through.

---

About Me: My expertise spans two decades, during which I’ve had the privilege to launch and elevate Topo Chico’s social media narrative and work closely with outdoor lifestyle brands and TV shows to craft engaging digital content. Amplify your digital footprint. I’m ready when you are.